Conservatives sued for right to misgender Club Q victim. The Supreme Court refused their appeal.

Conservatives sued for right to misgender Club Q victim. The Supreme Court refused their appeal.
LGBTQ


The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear a case brought by two transphobic activists claiming that their First Amendment rights were violated when they weren’t allowed to misgender a trans person during a legislative debate in Colorado.

The case involves two anti-trans activists, Rich Guggenheim of Gays Against Groomers (GAG) and Christina Goeke of Rocky Mountain Women’s Network, who testified in the state legislature against Tiara’s Law, a law that makes it easier for trans people with felony convictions to change their names.

Guggenheim and Goeke say that Democrats in the state legislature told witnesses that they would have to use “respectful discourse” and avoid “derogatory language” or “misgendering witnesses.” The two anti-LGBTQ+ activists refused to use Tiara’s first name or refer to her with she/her pronouns, and, after repeated warnings, had their testimony cut short.

So they sued a list of individual Democratic state legislators, arguing that their free speech was violated. They claim that they were silenced because they did not agree with “transgenderism,” a word conservatives use to present the state of being transgender as a political ideology instead of an identity. They also called referring to trans women with she/her pronouns part of a “pronoun ritual.” They accused the lawmakers of “abusing their authority to put a thumb on the scale of the public’s debate about transgenderism.”

The district court immediately dismissed their claim, citing legislators’ personal immunity for what happens in legislative proceedings. The plaintiffs appealed but the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal, citing legislative immunity.

They appealed to the Supreme Court, but the Supreme Court refused to hear their appeal without comment.

The bill was named after Tiara Latrice Kelley, a trans woman who could not change her name in the state due to a past felony conviction for sex work in the state of Florida. The fact that she couldn’t change her name meant that she struggled to obtain support that had been allocated for victims of the Club Q mass shooting, despite the fact that she was a performer at the nightclub, Colorado Newsline reported at the time. She told Westword that the bank charged with distributing the funds refused to hand over a check because it had her birth name on it, and “they didn’t believe” that a woman would have that first name. Kelley said it was “dehumanizing.”

“The reason why it’s important to put a name to this bill is because Tiara is a brave and important, strong woman in our community,” said state Rep. Lorena Garcia (D). “She has been willing to put herself and her life at risk for the trans community to have access to a right that is readily available to others.”

Tiara’s Law ultimately passed and was signed into law by out Gov. Jared Polis (D).

“I am really glad that future generations of trans people like myself have one less thing to worry about when trying to affirm their identity,” Kelley said when the bill passed, adding that she was going to change her name “as soon as possible.”

“I feel honored, I feel amazed, I feel proud of our legislators here in Colorado – most of them, at least.”

“We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case,” the Institute for Free Speech, which represented the defendants, said in a statement. The organization in the past has referred to “trans ideology” as requiring “adherents” to call a “trans-identifying person” by their “preferred” pronouns and “adopted trans name,” all transphobic dog whistles.

Political operative Jaimee Michell founded Gays Against Groomers in 2022.The Southern Poverty Law Centercalls the group “one of the most notable propagators of anti-trans rhetoric.” It claims to oppose the “sexualization and indoctrination of children,” which largely means opposing transgender-inclusive social policies, LGBTQ+ content in schools, and all-ages drag performances.

In 2024, Media Matters published a report titled“Grifter Gays” detailing the lie that Gays Against Groomers is a grassroots organization and identifying founder Michell and her fellow co-chair David Leatherwood as longtime conspiracy-peddling, pro-Trump operatives with deep ties to the likes of Trump-whisperer Roger Stone and “Stop the Steal” founder Ali Alexander, another gay man who says he is“battling with same-sex attraction.”

Subscribe to theLGBTQ Nation newsletterand be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.

View Original Article Here

Articles You May Like

Book Riots Deals of the Day for November 13, 2026
James Gunns HBO Max Superman Series Officially Returns With New Episode In 2 Weeks Despite DC Exit
Look Cinemas Takes Over Pasadenas IPic Theater, Will Reopen In December Amid Resurgence Of LA Area Screens
Best Indie Crime Novel of 2026 Shortlist | Crime Fiction Lover
Watch a soldier loudly yell at Pete Hegseth for laughing at a soldiers grave