
Just like in our Best Indie category, here in Best Debut we’re looking at crime novels that bring something fresh, new and different to the genre. And here at Crime Fiction Lover, we think that’s something worth celebrating. Yes, crime fiction is a genre and as such, readers come to it with certain expectations. But that doesn’t mean it can’t change, evolve and entertain us in new and different ways.
We’re proud to unveil the shortlist for this category, as nominated by Crime Fiction Lover readers. Here, we expand a little on each of the shortlisted entries and then we hand it over to you to vote on which you believe to be the best. And, if you’re curious, you can see the shortlists for our 2026 awards right here.
Click here to vote in THE CRIME FICTION LOVE AWARDS 2026.
The Fifteenth Man by William Cook

Journalist turned debut crime writer William Cook introduces Anglo-German journalist Michael Braun in The Fifteenth Man, set in Berlin in 1990. The wall has fallen and the country is planning reunification, but there are still old Nazis out there and Braun is determined to root them out – even if his employers don’t seem that interested any more. In a crowded genre, Cook is bringing something new to the table in “a fast-paced noir novel… with a new voice that feels urgent” according to Crime Fiction Lover reviewer Chris Connor. This is a compelling book that shies away from Hollywood glamour and evokes a period of fairly recent history in a way that is both fresh and authentic. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
A Bad, Bad Place by Frances Crawford

It’s already won a slew of awards – can debutant Frances Crawford round off the year on a high, CFL readers? A Bad, Bad Place is set in Possilpark, a working-class area of Glasgow, which is where 12-year-old Janey Devine lives with her grandmother and her dog, Sid Vicious. It’s Sid who finds the body which is about to turn Janey’s life upside down. This is a book with layers of realism that really draw you in and don’t let go as the tension ramps up. Our reviewer called it absorbing and character-driven, with none other than our 2024 Best Author winner Ian Rankin describing the book as “clever, authentic, and humanewith unforgettable protagonists and pitch-black humour.” Enough said. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
A Gift Before Dying by Malcolm Kempt

Traditional police procedural meets supernatural thriller in the chilling (and chilly) A Gift Before Dying – it is set in the Arctic Circle, after all. This bleak setting gives Nordic noir a run for its money, with intertwining themes of poverty, despair, loss of traditions and violence. This is not a book for the faint-hearted, offering a visceral and grim read – but it’s at the vanguard of Arctic noir and marks Malcolm Kempt as a name to watch out for. Reviewers have called it “haunting, immersive, moving” and “aterrific, permafrosted mystery”, with our own reviewer commenting: “a chilling, essential addition to the crime fiction genre.” The To Be Read list just got another candidate. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
The Nancys and the Case of the Missing Necklace by RWR McDonald

Anyone who enjoyed reading crime novels as a child is about to find their tribe in this debut by New Zealand author RWR McDonald – and it’s that feeling of utter belonging that makes it such a brilliant first book. Our antipodean followers may query why The Nancys and the Case of the Missing Necklace is even in this category – it arrived there in 2019, after all – but thanks to Orenda Books the rest of us can now get acquainted with 11-year-old Tippy Chan, her uncle Pike and his boyfriend Devon, who are The Nancys of the title. Who knew good ol’ Nancy Drew could be the inspiration for such a wonderful trio of would-be sleuths? Spot-on settings and characterisation added to a liberal dollop of light heartedness make this a book well worth your reading time. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
The Murder at World’s End by Ross Montgomery

Cosy crime is on the up and up, and Ross Montgomery’s The Murder at World’s End has proved to be a welcome addition to that subgenre. Get ready for an historical crime novel with a locked-room whodunnit at its very heart. It’s autumn 1910, and on a windswept island off the Cornish coast the Viscount of Tithe Hall is in a tizzy preparing for the apocalypse that will be triggered by the arrival of Halley’s Comet. As we all know, the world didn’t end, but there’s plenty of drama in store in a novel that offers a “unique blend of wit, warmth and atmospheric suspense ensures it stands on its own merits,” according to our five-star review by Erin Britton. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
Shrink Solves Murder by Philippa Perry

What a great title – and the pages inside back it up! Psychotherapist and bestselling writer Philippa Perry uses her skills as a people person to create utterly believable characters in Shrink Solves Murder, her first foray into crime fiction. It’s not so much a whodunnit as a whydunnit and all delivered with a dry humour. Our protagonist is Patricia Phillips, a psychotherapist who lives in Sussex. Her pet hates are irresponsible dog walkers and unsightly planning applications, but Pat is about to find something else to occupy her time when one of her clients is found at the bottom of the nearby cliffs after apparently killing himself. The title probably gives a clue as to what happens next in a book our reviewer described as “smart, funny and psychologically astute” before giving it five stars. Read our review here.
Buy now on Amazon
